Trump Doubles Down On Vow To End 'Crazy' Birthright Citizenship

01 November, 2018, 09:14 | Author: Orlando Hughes
  • Trump wants to end birthright citizenship in the U.S.

US President Donald Trump has once again sparked a furor of constitutional law studies by politicos by claiming he can end birthright citizenship in the US all by himself. "At its core, birthright citizenship is what our 14th Amendment is all about".

An executive order would spark an uphill legal battle for Trump about whether the president has the unilateral ability to declare that children born in the USA to those living here illegally aren't citizens.

"We have to take a look at that legislation", Donnelly said during a debate on Tuesday evening about a bill that would revoke the right, adding, "I'd want to see that legislation and make sure it was constitutional and review it first".

"We don't do stunts", Mattis said Wednesday.

Trump did not say when he would sign the order, and some of his past promises to use executive action have gone unfulfilled. "That is a far cry from what President Trump is trying to do".

"They're playing all of us", said David W. Leopold, an immigration attorney and counsel to the immigration advocacy group America's Voice.

Trump floated the idea of changing that in a TV interview with Axios, excerpts of which were made public on Tuesday.

In fact, many legal scholars say the 14th Amendment is clear in conferring citizenship on people born in the United States. Keep in mind [former Democratic Senator] Harry Reid actually attempted to pass a law - well, introduced it - about 30 years ago that actually would have deprived children born in the United States of illegal aliens of citizenship.

Already, even some of the President's defenders downplayed the prospects of successfully ending birthright citizenship by executive order.

The words of a top Democrat proclaiming that "no sane country" would provide birthright citizenship to the children of non-residents was promoted by President Donald Trump on October 31 as he argued that the Supreme Court will ultimately decide the issue.

PM Modi reaches Kevadiya to unveil Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel’s Statue Of Unity
The Statue of Unity is a 3.5-hour drive from the major city of Ahmedabad and a two-hour drive from the Vadodara airport. The statue is part of Modi's poll promise which helped the BJP come to power in 2014 by defeating the Congress.

Trump campaigned on building a wall on the border with Mexico and reforming USA immigration laws.

"For 130 years there's an uninterrupted stream of case law, including cases written by the Wong Kim Ark justice, Horace Gray, saying that if you come here without consent and you do not have legal status, it is, in the most literal and physical sense, as if you are standing outside of our boundaries in terms of access to the courts, in terms of rights, in terms of everything", Horowitz said.

When asked after the debate about ending birthright citizenship, Yoder told reporters that if the USA secured its borders adequately, "That's not an issue then".

"We're the only country in the world where a person comes in, has a baby, and the baby is essentially a citizen of the United States for 85 years with all of those benefits", Trump said in an interview for "Axios on HBO".

The Supreme Court has never ruled squarely about the clause's application to children of immigrants who are in the USA illegally. It is not covered by the 14th Amendment because of the words 'subject to the jurisdiction thereof.

"But the Supreme Court of the United States has never ruled on whether or not the language of the 14th amendment, subject to the jurisdiction thereof, applies specifically to people who are in the country illegally", Pence said. The White House did not respond to a request for comment.

Many legal scholars agree.

The country is facing a massive backlog of immigration cases - some 700,000 - and there are more and more families coming across the border from Central America - groups who can not be simply returned over the border.

More broadly, Trump's view that USA -born children of foreigners live a lifetime of taking "all those benefits" ignores the taxes they pay, the work they do and their other contributions to society.

Recommended:

  • Vienna Open - Kei Nishikori to face Kevin Anderson in final

    Vienna Open - Kei Nishikori to face Kevin Anderson in final

    Now in ninth place, Nishikori with a win could move to within 125 points of the cut for the eight-man event in London next month. The 11th-ranked Nishikori is after his 12th career title but first since winning in Memphis in February 2016.
    Blasphemy case: Pakistan Supreme Court overturns Asia Bibi's death sentence

    Blasphemy case: Pakistan Supreme Court overturns Asia Bibi's death sentence

    The workers had refused to drink from a bucket of water Asia Bibi had touched because she was not Muslim. It is a case which has drawn global attention to Pakistan's blasphemy laws and divided the nation.
    Asia stocks lose $5 trillion this year

    Asia stocks lose $5 trillion this year

    Dow futures erased losses on Wednesday after Boeing posted stronger-than-forecast quarterly earnings. Futures on the Nasdaq 100 and Dow Jones Industrial Average climbed 0.5% and 0.2% respectively.
  • RBI governor Urjit Patel may consider resigning

    RBI governor Urjit Patel may consider resigning

    Another report in the Times of India said the government had mentioned the rule to the RBI in consultations, without invoking it. For the goal , extensive consultations on several issues take place between the government and the RBI from time to time.
    Afghan Residents Risk Their Lives To Vote In Delayed Kandahar Poll

    Afghan Residents Risk Their Lives To Vote In Delayed Kandahar Poll

    Miller escaped unhurt, but US Brigadier General Jeffrey Smiley was among 13 people wounded in the shooting claimed by the Taliban. Ibrahimi said 111 candidates were vying for 11 seats in Parliament from southern Kandahar in Afghanistan's 249-seat chamber.
    Los Angeles Dodgers outlast Boston Red Sox in longest World Series game

    Los Angeles Dodgers outlast Boston Red Sox in longest World Series game

    Rodriguez returns after throwing just six pitches in striking out Joc Pederson for the final out of the fifth inning Friday. Muncy would decide the issue five innings later after both teams had nearly emptied their lineups using nine pitchers each.
  • OnePlus 6T India Launch Set for Tonight

    OnePlus 6T India Launch Set for Tonight

    There aren't a lot of new features on the software side of things, barring new camera features and new navigation gestures. The company terms this feature as Screen Unlock and it claims it is the fastest in-screen fingerprint sensor in the world.
    Pistons still unbeaten after 110-103 win over Cleveland

    Pistons still unbeaten after 110-103 win over Cleveland

    In Orlando, Damian Lillard's second-half scoring spree helped propel Portland to a 128-114 victory. The Celtics hit nine 3-pointers in the third quarter after failing to make one in the first half.
    Google makes it easier to clear your recent Search activity

    Google makes it easier to clear your recent Search activity

    Google also made it a little easier to find privacy controls related to Search, like ad personalization settings (see below). The new controls seem to be in response to a growing trend with tech companies being pulled up on issues of privacy.
  • Mattis Says Khashoggi Killing Could Destabilize Middle East

    Mattis Says Khashoggi Killing Could Destabilize Middle East

    He said he doesn't know the details of the investigation and called the media's coverage of the events "hysterical". Al-Jubeir claimed that Saudi authorities are trying to be transparent, but said the media makes it hard .
    No Messi or Ronaldo but Clasico could still define season

    No Messi or Ronaldo but Clasico could still define season

    A win will ease the pressure off the manager's back and the fans will have the first bragging rights at their oppositions. On the players' support, Lopetegui also said, "Obviously, I trust them and they trust me".
    Girls, 11 and 12, 'planned to drink blood of classmates', police say

    Girls, 11 and 12, 'planned to drink blood of classmates', police say

    The girls remain in police custody, and a school system officials said the school will be filing for expulsion. Among the charges they face: conspiracy to commit first-degree murder and possession of a weapon at school.


Popular

Team Winx 'Emotional' After Mare's Electric Record-Setting Cox Plate Victory
Hugh Bowman rides Winx during Breakfast with the Best. "We will all sit down and talk about her future in a few weeks, " Waller said. "I don't think I need to say anything".

Cent Jumps In Nicki Minaj And Steve Madden Feud
Things got worse before they got better, though, and the calls for peace only came after the two went at it like it was their job. Cardi B was Little Mix's backup option for their song because Nicki Minaj took her damn sweet time and had them panicking.

References of the new iPad Pro design found in the iOS code
All in all, Apple new strategy of upgrading gadgets in all of its product categories is a departure from the company's old ways. The A12 Bionic that's tucked inside the new iPhone Xs and XR is, without doubt, one of the fastest processors now on the market.

Saudi van with 3 suitcases leaves Istanbul consulate
Dozens of Western officials, bankers and executives boycotted a major investment conference in Riyadh this week. Mr Jubeir, however, insisted that US-Saudi relations would weather the fallout of Khashoggi's murder.

Mauricio Pochettino admits Spurs’ fine start masks stadium frustration
Mauricio Pochettino says he is enduring his "worst feeling" as Tottenham boss this season, despite guiding them to their best Premier League start.

Over the weekend: German election results putting pressure on Merkel
The chancellor threw her weight behind her friend in Hesse and visited him four times on the campaign trail in recent weeks. But the CDU and ecologist Greens may lack sufficient support to renew their ruling alliance in the state.

Turkey 'shares all evidence' with Central Intelligence Agency chief relating to Khashoggi killing
Dozens of government and business leaders have pulled out, but Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman appeared at the event on Tuesday. Saudi state oil giant Saudi Aramco said it signed deals with 15 worldwide partners worth more than $34bn.

Woman stabs 14 kids in China kindergarten
Video from the hospital showed adults wailing in grief as children covered in blood were rushed from ambulances into the building. China has suffered a number of such incidents in recent years, blamed largely on the mentally ill or people bearing grudges.

Netanyahu visits Oman, which has no diplomatic ties with Israel
Earlier this week, Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas also visited the Persian Gulf Arab state for three days. His office added that it formed part of a policy of "deepening relations with the states of the region".

Tesla delivers on Elon Musk’s 3Q profit pledge
Such credit sales pushed Tesla to a profit in its third-quarter of 2016, one of two times it has been in the black so far. Tesla on Wednesday posted a surprise third-quarter profit thanks to strong revenue generated by its Model 3 sedan.